Howlers New Era Cap Lineup: 59FIFTY vs 9TWENTY vs 9FORTY
By Hill City Howlers Official Store | Published: 2026-11-02
Category: Comparisons
Compare the Howlers' 59FIFTY fitted, 9TWENTY adjustable, and women's 9FORTY caps on fit, sizing, and style to pick your game-day hat.
Quick answer
Choose the 59FIFTY if you want a fitted, structured look and know your cap size; pick the 9TWENTY for an adjustable, relaxed fit in team colors; and go with the women's 9FORTY for a tailored adjustable fit. Each offers a different trade-off between precision, flexibility, and style.
Fitted precision vs adjustable ease
The biggest decision is whether you want a fitted cap or an adjustable one. The 59FIFTY is fitted, so it stays put without straps or snaps, but you need to know your size. The 9TWENTY and women's 9FORTY are adjustable, giving you room to fine-tune the fit or share the cap.
If you're between sizes, an adjustable cap is more forgiving. If you want a clean, strap-free look, the 59FIFTY is the way to go.
Sizing ranges and what they mean
The 59FIFTY comes in fitted sizes from 7 to 8, which covers a range of head circumferences. That precision is great if you know your size, but it means you can't adjust on the fly. The 9TWENTY and 9FORTY use adjustable closures, so one size accommodates many wearers.
For a first New Era cap, adjustable is often the safer bet. For a seasoned cap wearer, the 59FIFTY's fitted feel is hard to beat.
Style and design differences
The 59FIFTY features a custom alternate script design that stands out, while the 9TWENTY shows the alternate jersey script in Blue, Black, or Gray. The women's 9FORTY has a primary design tailored for women. Your choice may come down to which logo style you prefer and whether you want a women's-specific cut.
All three are official New Era caps, so quality is consistent across the lineup.
Key trade-offs
- 59FIFTY: precision vs commitment: You get a fitted, structured cap that stays put, but you must know your size (7–8) and can't adjust it. Best for fans who already own fitted caps. Measure your head before ordering; no exchanges for fit if you guess wrong.
- 9TWENTY: flexibility vs structure: The adjustable closure accommodates a range of sizes and lets you tweak the fit, but the crown may feel less rigid than a fitted cap. Available in three team colors. Great for sharing or if you're unsure of your size.
- Women's 9FORTY: tailored fit vs unisex options: Designed specifically for women with an adjustable closure, offering a more tailored fit than unisex caps. If you prefer a unisex cut, consider the 9TWENTY. Check the women's sizing chart if you're between sizes.
Product facts
- Hill City Howlers New Era 9TWENTY Alternate 1 Jersey Script Cap: Adjustable closure and available in Blue, Black, and Gray. You get a customizable fit and color options to match your gear.
Hill City Howlers New Era 9TWENTY Alternate 1 Jersey Script Cap - Hill City Howlers New Era Custom Alternate 2 Script 59FIFTY Cap: Fitted sizes from 7 to 8 and a bold alternate script design. If you know your size, you get a precise, strap-free fit with a standout look.
Hill City Howlers New Era Custom Alternate 2 Script 59FIFTY Cap - Hill City Howlers New Era Women's 9FORTY Primary Cap: Women's-specific design with adjustable fit. It's tailored for a better fit on women's heads, with the flexibility of adjustment.
Which cap fits your game-day style?
Best for
- Fans who know their fitted size and want a structured, strap-free look (59FIFTY)
- Fans who want an adjustable, versatile cap in multiple colors (9TWENTY)
- Women looking for a tailored, adjustable fit (women's 9FORTY)
Not for
- Anyone unsure of their head size (choose adjustable instead of 59FIFTY)
- Fans who prefer a women's-specific cut (choose 9FORTY over unisex options)
- Those who want a rigid, fitted feel (avoid adjustable caps)
